State Prep Championsip: Why Serra is huge underdog to Mater Dei

Quarterback Elijah Brown #12 of Mater Dei Monarchs scrambles again st the Serra Padres in the second half of a 2021 CIF State Football Championship Bowl Game at Saddleback College in Mission Viejo on Saturday, December 11, 2021
Quarterback Elijah Brown #12 of Mater Dei Monarchs scrambles again st the Serra Padres in the second half of a 2021 CIF State Football Championship Bowl Game at Saddleback College in Mission Viejo on Saturday, December 11, 2021

Mater Dei vs. Serra is a culture clash betwen SoCal and NorCal

Championship Game Details here

Since 2016, one of the two Southern California superpowers has ended the season with an Open Division state title – and not a single one of the games has been decided by fewer than 14 points.

The domination of the two schools, separated by 24 miles, was intriguing enough for the New York Times to write a 2,300-word feature in 2021 titled, “California’s High School Football Powerhouses Feed the College Game.”

In the story, the Times describes how the rise began:

A little more than a decade ago, St. John Bosco was at a crossroads. Enrollment, which had peaked in 2001, had plummeted by one-third to fewer than 700 in the wake of the Great Recession. “We were on the ropes,” said Paul Escala, who was hired as St. John Bosco’s president in 2010 and is now the superintendent of schools for the Archdiocese of Los Angeles.

The school decided football could be its salvation.

Escala asked the alumni to bet on a vision of St. John Bosco as a college prep school — in the arts, academics and athletics. It would rely on data to target students who could afford a premium education and would be more strategic in delivering financial aid. “That was music to my ears,” said {football coach Jason} Negro, who was hired months before Escala.

Mater Dei, which missed the playoffs in 2011, followed Bosco’s lead, with former coach Bruce Rollinson asking Negro how the Bellflower school was excelling, according to the Times.

Both schools became heavily involved in youth football. Both hired top-notch assistants. Both started replacing outgoing stars with star transfers — and not just from their backyard, taking advantage of CIF bylaw revisions in 2012 and 2017. Both became not only state powerhouses but mythical national champions, too.

One player the Times interviewed transferred to Mater Dei from Bakersfield, commuting 150 miles each way with his mother. The player committed to Texas.

“I knew I’d never regret this,” the player’s mother said.

Serra didn’t have any transfers this season. It had four in 2022 and one (Smith, who moved from Sacramento) in 2021.

The transfer game is different in Southern California, Serra coach Patrick Walsh said.

Asked if he wants to jump into that pool, Walsh added, “Staring here in front of a week like this, the answer would be yes. But looking at the previous 12, 13 weeks, the answer would be no because that is not the culture of Northern California football as it stands right now.”

For Walsh, the transfer issue boils down to a philosophical difference.

That difference is choosing or not choosing to replace players who have worked years for starting spots — and bought into team culture — with high-profile transfers.

“I want to be very, very clear,” Walsh said. “People transfer schools. Everyone in our section, everyone in our league has kids transfer in. We’ve had kids transfer out. It’s not like people are never going to transfer again.

“It’s more of the systemic approach to getting or attracting a ton of transfers and the cost of that is lifelong Padres families that have committed to our program as freshmen – not only making sacrifices to get to school but also because we’re a private school, financially – and then senior year saying, ‘Sorry, you’re not playing because we have a five-star transfer.’ That is hard for me to deal with.”

Serra has much of what Bosco and Mater Dei have – elite coaching, administrative support, good facilities and a brand name. It even has famous alums (Tom Brady, Barry Bonds).

The difference is Serra’s roster is not filled with four- and five-star talent.

It is unclear the number of transfers Mater Dei, now led by former assistant Frank McManus, has this season. But this much is clear: As with the state game against Mater Dei in 2021 and Bosco last season, Serra is facing one heck of a climb Saturday night, probably an impossible climb.

If the game unfolds as expected, another blowout on the state’s biggest stage, CIF officials must address the elephant in the room: How much longer can this go on? And what can be done to level the playing field?

See San Jose Mercury Prep Coverage here

Recent Stories

NFHS Streaming Games of Week: Watch best preps in country; support your high school

          NFHS — the National Federation of High School Broadcasting Network— is a fast-growing streaming ...

Recruiting Battles Heat Up

The lifeblood of college athletic programs is dynamic athletic prospects. With the college football season only three weeks away, the recruiting battles for 2025 ...

Elite 11: Texas QB steals the show

In an annual peek at future pros — and a harbinger of Heismans — Duncanville High’s lithe and lanky Keelon Russell stole the show this week at prep football’s prestigious ...

Nebraska QB Dylan Raiola, WR Carter Nelson connect in Polynesian Bowl win

  Jan 19, 2024  In the final game of their high school careers, Dylan Raiola and Carter Nelson were building for the future. Taking part in the Polynesian ...

Big Win for Little Man in Lopsided Under Armour Prep All-Star Game

After several days of entertaining practices featuring the top high school players in the 2024 High School class, the Under Armour All-America Game was a runaway ...

HSFA Rankings: Mater Dei No. 1 in Nation -- Again!

Mater Dei (Santa Ana, California) finishes 2023 where it started, at the top of the High School Football America 100 national rankings, powered by NFL Play Football. ...

Is NIL impacting prep NLI ? You Betchya — Details on Ohio State's Anxious Day

Ohio State was kept in a state of angst until 10 p.m. Wednesday, Dec. 20, the first of a three-day early-signing window for high school recruits. That's when the ...

So who leapfrogged Raiola to be No. 1 QB recruit? Just. . . Sayin

See full story by ESPN's Paolo Uggetti and recruiting coverage here (Uggetti asks: Is Julian Sayin the next great Alabama quarterback? Read Uggetti's story below ...

Hall of Football's Top 19 Uncommitted Preps as Signing Window Opens

The day before we open the early prep signing window, 19 of the top 386 recruits in the class of 2024 remain uncommitted on the Hall of Football/NFLDraftScout.com ...

QB Raiola Flips to Nebraska as Early Prep Signing Window Nears

With the early, three-day high school signing period starting Wednesday (Dec. 20), there was a flurry of activity with visits and flips the last few days. Most ...
Read More Stories