Miller: Which QB interloper will spoil Super Bowl matchup?
Vikings quarterback Case Keenum hopes to lead his team to Super Bowl LII.
Super Bowl history is filled with matchups of quarterbacks bound for the Hall of Fame: Montana vs. Marino, Bradshaw vs. Staubach (twice), Aikman vs. Kelly (twice), Elway vs. Favre.
Not this year.
As we head into conference championship weekend, not only is there no possibility of a matchup of historic proportion, the fact is that Super Bowl LII will likely match a Hall of Fame-bound QB against one who quite possibly could be jettisoned by his current team as soon as the season is over.
How strange is that?
Certainly, there have been Super Bowl quarterback matchups before pitting a guy with jewelry and resume against a nobody. Peyton Manning vs. Rex Grossman comes quickly to mind, or even Kurt Warner vs. Tom Brady - back when Brady was thought to be the interloper. Warner already had a Super Bowl ring at the time.
But the final four this year has a decidedly weird feel to it because Brady is the only quarterback with a pedigree among the four teams. In three of the four divisional playoff games last weekend, the quarterback with the resume was eliminated.
They were Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger and Matt Ryan, two of whom have led their team to Super Bowl titles and another who a year ago had the fourth highest passer rating in a Super Bowl game, but suffered a heartbreaking loss. In fact, Ryan's 144.1 passer rating in Super Bowl LI is the only one among the Super Bowl's 10 highest passer ratings that belongs to a losing quarterback.
Nonetheless, those three were eliminated by teams whose quarterbacks were named Case Keenum, Blake Bortles and Nick Foles. Brady has won 26 post-season games as a starting quarterback. Until two weeks ago, none of those other three ever had won a post-season game and only Foles had even played in one.
In fact, none of the three non-Brady quarterbacks in the final four have won as many games, regular season and post-season combined, as Brady has won just in the post-season. In case you were wondering, Brady has won 196 regular-season games to go along with his 26 post-season wins, including five Super-Bowl victories. Peyton Manning and Brett Favre are the only quarterbacks within 50 victories of Brady.
Of course, when Brady led the Patriots to their shocking championship in the 2001 season, no one had a clue what was ahead for him, either. But we at least had a bit of a hint what the Patriots thought because after Brady had to leave the AFC Championship Game with an injury, and veteran Drew Bledsoe came in and passed for New England's only offensive touchdown, head coach Bill Belichick went back to the kid for the Super Bowl rather than Bledsoe, who had missed much of the season due to injury.
And, after the season was done, the Patriots cut ties with Bledsoe.
Obviously, we don't know what will happen with the three little-known quarterbacks still in the running this year, but we do know that two of them are playing only because of injuries to the regular starter, and, unlike the 2001 situation with Brady, there is every likelihood they will be looking for work next year.
Those two are Nick Foles, who is playing for the Eagles only because Carson Wentz, their sensational second-year guy, suffered a season-ending injury in early December, and Case Keenum, who is playing for the Vikings only because of injuries to Sam Bradford and Teddy Bridgewater. It is a measure of the Vikings' lack of commitment to Keenum, the starter since September, that Bradford, Bridgewater and even Kyle Sloter, an undrafted rookie, remain on the 53-man roster.
Likewise, his two playoff victories still haven't convinced a lot of folks in Jacksonville that Blake Bortles is the long-term future at quarterback for the Jaguars. After winning only 11 games in his first three NFL seasons, Bortles has won a dozen this year including playoffs, yet there is no known move by the Jaguars to sign him to a long-term contract. Right now, he is scheduled to play the 2018 season under his option year worth $19 million.
One reason for that skepticism could well be that Bortles' passer rating for the 2017 season, 84.7, ranked 20th in the NFL, behind such luminaries as Josh McCown of the Jets and Tyrod Taylor of the Bills, among others.
Which brings us back to Brady, whose passer rating this season, 102.8, was the third best in the NFL and the sixth of his career above 100. Not saying it's impossible, but were any team except the Patriots to win Super Bowl LII, it would rank with the Jets in Super Bowl III and that Brady-Warner matchup in Super Bowl XXXVI36 among the most stunning upsets of all time.
Football isn't only about the quarterbacks, of course. But it's hard to get past that part of the game.
Ira Miller is an award-winning sportswriter who has covered the National Football League for more than five decades and is a member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame Selection Committee. He is a national columnist for The Sports Xchange.
Recent Stories
Rams hard at work despite earning bye
The Los Angeles Rams will continue to stay hard at work despite earning a bye through the wild-card round of the NFL playoffs.
Players will continue to visit the ...
Packers' lost season includes losing Rodgers to concussion
Green Bay's 6-9-1 season ended with Aaron Rodgers getting knocked out of Sunday's 31-0 loss to the Detroit Lions with a concussion. That was dubious and fitting ...
49ers will retain defensive coordinator Saleh
The San Francisco 49ers gave up a lot of points and did not force many turnovers, but Robert Saleh will return for his third season as the 49ers' defensive coordinator, ...
GM Licht says Winston is Bucs' quarterback
Dirk Koetter was fired as the Tampa Bay Buccaneers' head coach on Sunday, but his quarterback will be staying.
General manager Jason Licht, who will lead the search ...
Chargers get another chance against Ravens
The Los Angeles Chargers didn't have to wait long for a chance to avenge their Week 16 loss to the Baltimore Ravens.
Los Angeles was shut down by Baltimore's stout ...
Latest Player Notes
How a Wisconsin legend got his German protégé into Badgers pro day
Mar 15, 2024
Marlon Werthmann put his life on hold for the opportunity in front of him Friday at the McClain Center.Werthmann ...
Why former Wisconsin football running back Braelon Allen didn't run the 40 at pro day
Mar 15, 2024
Braelon Allen’s sweat covered his shirt and dripped off his beard as he approached a group of reporters Friday.The ...
How can UW recruit its best class ever? It starts with these five prospects
By Andy Yamashita
Seattle Times staff reporter
Jedd Fisch has lofty recruiting goals at Washington. He didn’t waste any ...
Texas football kicks off spring practice Tuesday. We answer 24 questions for the 2024 team
Things certainly look fresh for the 2024 college football season, especially on the Texas campus.There’s a new conference ...
College Football Playoff: Conferences solve their differences (for now) and agree on general framework for 2026 and beyond
The FBS conferences and Notre Dame agreed on Friday to continue the College Football Playoff beyond the 2025 season, signing ...
Ball security, leadership key as Aztecs look to identify starting quarterback
San Diego State seemingly auditions a new starting quarterback on an annual basis.In the past 12 years, the Aztecs have opened ...
Results and more: A look at what happened at Penn State football’s Pro Day inside Holuba Hall
Most of those at Penn State’s Pro Day Friday were relatively quiet throughout the afternoon’s workouts, but there was one ...
Defense dominates first two weeks of Oregon State spring practice as Beavers ready for 2-week breather
CORVALLIS – Oregon State hit the break of spring practices Saturday, not exactly the midpoint but a good place to assess ...
Dillon Gabriel to have similar input, autonomy as Bo Nix had in Oregon’s offense
Published Mar. 16, 2024, 6:26 p.m.By James CrepeaEUGENE — Dillon Gabriel will have much of the same autonomy as Bo Nix did ...
Two transfers, one underclassman who impressed in Missouri football's spring game
With that, spring camp’s a wrap.Missouri football held its Black & Gold spring game Saturday in front of a healthy crowd ...